| Name |
Level |
| Bible Baptist Christian Academy |
Mixed Grades |
| Cherry Ridge School |
Elementary |
| Christian School of York |
Mixed Grades |
| Garbers Mennonite School |
Mixed Grades |
| Grace Academy |
Elementary |
| Grace Words Christian Academy |
Secondary |
| High Road School of York |
Mixed Grades |
| Holy Trinity Catholic School |
Elementary |
| Hope Christian School of Hanover |
Mixed Grades |
| Keystone Christian Academy - York |
Mixed Grades |
| Kralltown Mennonite School |
Elementary |
| Lighthouse Christian School |
Mixed Grades |
| Logos Academy |
Mixed Grades |
| Old Paths Christian Academy |
Elementary |
| Pleasant Hill Christian School |
Mixed Grades |
| Red Lion Christian School |
Mixed Grades |
| Rolling Ridge School |
Elementary |
| Shrewsbury Christian Academy |
Elementary |
| Singing Meadow School |
Mixed Grades |
| Smith Hollow School Att Henery Kinsinger |
Elementary |
| St. John the Baptist School |
Elementary |
| St. Joseph Catholic School |
Elementary |
| St. Joseph School |
Elementary |
| St. Rose of Lima School |
Elementary |
| Sunnyburn School |
Elementary |
| Tidings of Peace Christian School |
Mixed Grades |
| York Adventist Christian School |
Elementary |
| York Country Day School |
Mixed Grades |